October 16th, 1995. Geraldo Rivera on his namesake talk show brings us the story of twin brothers who dated the same woman.
“I don’t know how she could do something to him like that, I mean he is the sweetest guy…”
We hear the details of how Jamie and Laurie were going steady, only for Laurie to connect with his twin brother while Jamie is away on a fishing trip. Jamie and his current girlfriend Kelly are on stage, while twin brother Joey and Laurie come on the set later in this segment to set things straight. The story remains disputed.
This day, Geraldo’s television history.